Всем привет! я новичок, учусь моделингу. Делал светильник Strala из Ikea, в форме звезды.
Отверстия хотел сделать с применением Proboolean. Check Operands For Self Intersection
Шаря на форумах нашел причину косяка, — кривая геометрия пересекаемой фигуры. В моем случае звезды. Еще на этапе построения ее, меня смущало как ее грани подсвечены. К сожалению очистил стек и придется объяснять как я ее построил. Сплайном посторил Star} Edit Poly}Выставил в середине координат ее}Инструментом Cut нарезал грани и образовавшуюся точку выровнял посередине и сместил затем} потом Summetry применил. Понял потом что геометрия косячная когда начал двигать вершины, образуются разрывы. Пытался Weldить их, не получается. Файл с моделью прилагается. Подскажите как исправить ошибку!
-
1 012 КБ
Просмотров: 285
Последнее редактирование:
в лшюбом случае такую гоеметрию буль не вывезет. Ее надо разбить на маленькие полигоны. Квадрифай мешь
в лшюбом случае такую гоеметрию буль не вывезет. Ее надо разбить на маленькие полигоны. Квадрифай мешь
Я читал что Proboolean отличает как раз от Boolean то что ей НЕ нужна мелкая сетка чтобы наделать отверстий, поправьте если не прав.
Меня больше интересует как построить такую форму замкнутой (сшитой по всей поверхности). В этой звезде скажем удалить один полигон, нельзя инструметом Loop потом выбрать грани и Кэпом вернуть полигон на место. Может скрипт есть волшебный чтобы косяки такие править
Quad remesher для 3Ds MAX
решит твои проблемы. ссыль на ютуб
но изучать топологию все равно надо
ну да именно,,
тольк наверно лучше будет сначала одну сторону продрявить, удалить торчалки, потом проарраить до цельной звезды, повелдить или покалапсить вершины стыков,
наложить Shell
и потом уже отсиметрить заднюю стенку,,
чтоб получилась цельная пустая звезда как сделанная из картона с дырочками %))
Hello,
I have two surfaces (AutoCAD Civil 3D Surfaces). I need to create Solid area between them.
But standart AutoCAD operations haven`t helped me — functions don`t want to work.
I try to use for this 3Ds Max. But everytime I want to use ProBoolean Substraction I have this message «Invalid Boolean. Check operands for self intersection».
I use this sequence:
1) Import by Civil View two surfaces in .vsp3d
2) Convert two imported surfaces in Editable Poly
3) Use STL check modifier (all options) — to check and clean geometry
4) Use Vertex Weld Modifier (threshold 0.01 — 1 santimeter) — to check and clean geometry
5) Extrude up two surfaces by poligons using Editable Poly Modifier. Warning: Surface, which has word in name «Base» is default lower, than surface, which has word in name «Top». So I extrude «Base» surface lower than «Top».
6) Use ProBoolean Substraction to substract from «Base» goal «Top» Surface — BUT ALL PROCESS HAS BEEN CRASHED!!! I have a message.
Can you recommend any workaround, way to create solid area between two surfaces?
What I`m doing wrong?
Finally I need to have solid in AutoCAD. How can i export results to solid object (I try to use export to .sat — but in AutoCAD I had strange graphic)?
I attached all files:
- 2 Surfaces.vsp3d — file for opening Surfaces through Civil View in 3Ds Max
- Faces.dwg — AutoCAD Drawing with faces. Please see the names of layers where surface located
- 2015.max — 3Ds Max project 2015
- Max.max — 3Ds Max project (I saved it in 2018 version)
Also I recorded a screencast where I demostrated workflow (link http://autode.sk/2zeQr63).
Please, help me, I need to make this solid as soon as possible.
PaLbI4
Как из одного объемного объекта «вычесть» другой?
То есть, что бы в одном объекте образовалась дыра в форме другого. Например мне нужно в цилиндре сделать дыру в цилиндрической формы с ось симметрии перпендикулярной оси самого цилиндра в котором хочу делать дырку
fartovij99
Если я правильно понял сообщение, то вот:
выбираешь первый цилиндр, компаунд обжектс, далее про булеан, затем отмечаешь сабстракшн (стоит по умолчанию щёлкаешь старт пикинг и выбираешь второй цилиндр. Не забудь отжать кнопку «старт пикинг» 
получается вот что
Чтобы так поставить цилиндры, то надо сначала один развернуть на 90 градусов, затем сделать Aline к другому и выставить по х, у, z везде center (их центры будут в одной точке).
з.ы. делай больше поликов.
fartovij99
лучше Pro Boolean, чем Boolean. Намного более адекватно вычитает/объединяет и т.д.
PaLbI4
я вибираю, Proboolean, затем substraction, нажимаю Start Picking и тыкаю мышкой во второй цилиндр (который у меня уже выставлен так как мне надо в пересечение с первым, но без всяких aline, как ты говорил, просто руками поставил его туда от балды) и он мне говорит -Invalid Boolean, потом Check Operands for self intersection, и такое ощущение что наоборот их соединяет в одну фигуру — потому что они становятся оба одного цвета (цвета первого цилиндра что не так?
PaLbI4
сработало, видимо я первый цилиндр не правильно выбирал
PaLbI4
а как количество полигонов у фигуры увеличить?
fartovij99
Когда создаёшь объект это, в принципе, пофиг.
пусть даже везде по 1 стоит.
Когда закладке редактирования уже можешь изменить их кол-во.
Перебарщивать тоже не стоит. С круглыми объектами просто старайся чтобы глазу не были заметны рёбра Помни что при увеличении поликов (не в таких мелких примерах, а в глобальных сценах увеличивается время рендера.
fartovij99
Если и другие способы, когда модель уже преобразована с помощью Edit Poly, но чувствую это пока не нужно.
Contents
- 1 Solved Invalid Boolean Autodesk Community
- 2 Spline And Boolean Problem And How To Solve It | Arabic
- 2.1 Conclusion
- 2.1.1 Related image with solved invalid boolean autodesk community
- 2.1.2 Related image with solved invalid boolean autodesk community
- 2.1 Conclusion
Pack your bags and join us on a whirlwind escapade to breathtaking destinations across the globe. Uncover hidden gems, discover local cultures, and ignite your wanderlust as we navigate the world of travel and inspire you to embark on unforgettable journeys in our Solved Invalid Boolean Autodesk Community section. The of reinstall to the is desktop service desktop Verify licensing licensing desktop and verify time that service- status autodesk how computer autodesk desktop licensing autodesk install and check settings- how autodesk service- service- uninstall date service- to see how licensing your running download licensing desktop autodesk the to uninstall
Solved Invalid Boolean Autodesk Community
Solved Invalid Boolean Autodesk Community
Solved: i ma trying to subtract the blue parts so i am left with holes in the red part. however i get a message invalid boolean, check operands knowledge network. When attempting to use boolean or proboolean on certain objects within a scene in 3ds max, the operation displays errors and the model disappears. 3ds max invalid boolean 3ds max check operands for self intersection boolean operation is applied to poor or incorrect model geometry.
Solved Objects Disappear After Boolean Operation Autodesk Community
Solved Objects Disappear After Boolean Operation Autodesk Community
3ds max 2023 help | fixing boolean problems | autodesk fixing boolean problems boolean operations are a powerful addition to your modeling toolbox; however, they can sometimes give strange or unexpected results. the boolean button is found on the create panel in the compound objects list; it allows you to join, subtract, intersect, and cut objects. Message 1 of 8 miamonica013 9089 views, 7 replies 08 10 2021 01:08 pm # error: unicodedecodeerror: file c: program files autodesk maya2022\python37\lib\encodings\cp1252.py line 23: ‘charmap’ codec can’t decode byte 0x8f in position 129: character maps to <undefined> #. Go to c:\program files\autodesk\adodis\v1. right click on the «removeodis.exe» and select run as administrator. if this options is not available, manually delete all the content in the folder. download and install the latest version of the autodesk on demand install service (odis). run the autodesk product install again. While doing any of the following for autocad: launching the software. accessing a command that brings up a dialog box. accessing a command that changes the user interface, such as producing a palette (external references, layer, properties, etc.) or contextual ribbon.
Solved Improper Use Of Boolean Expressions Autodesk Community
Solved Improper Use Of Boolean Expressions Autodesk Community
Go to c:\program files\autodesk\adodis\v1. right click on the «removeodis.exe» and select run as administrator. if this options is not available, manually delete all the content in the folder. download and install the latest version of the autodesk on demand install service (odis). run the autodesk product install again. While doing any of the following for autocad: launching the software. accessing a command that brings up a dialog box. accessing a command that changes the user interface, such as producing a palette (external references, layer, properties, etc.) or contextual ribbon. Verify that the autodesk desktop licensing service is running see how to check the status of autodesk desktop licensing service. uninstall and reinstall the autodesk desktop licensing service. how to uninstall autodesk desktop licensing service. how to download and install autodesk desktop licensing service. verify your computer date time settings. Select the boolean object. click to show the modify panel; or under compound objects, click boolean again. click add operand and click the sphere in the viewport or scene explorer. deselect the boolean object. create and place the cylinder if not already in position. select the boolean object.
Solved Invalid Block Autodesk Community
Solved Invalid Block Autodesk Community
Verify that the autodesk desktop licensing service is running see how to check the status of autodesk desktop licensing service. uninstall and reinstall the autodesk desktop licensing service. how to uninstall autodesk desktop licensing service. how to download and install autodesk desktop licensing service. verify your computer date time settings. Select the boolean object. click to show the modify panel; or under compound objects, click boolean again. click add operand and click the sphere in the viewport or scene explorer. deselect the boolean object. create and place the cylinder if not already in position. select the boolean object.
Spline And Boolean Problem And How To Solve It | Arabic
Spline And Boolean Problem And How To Solve It | Arabic
boolean operations in maya 2023. a quick tutorial #short i love that preview boolean option. autodesk 3ds max 2021 essential training preparing boolean operands. hi creators! booleans have improved dramatically since the previous maya version. in this video tutorial, we will go over live signup news letter: goo.gl 2orjki subscribe: goo.gl mj4exu instagram: goo.gl e3suf5 for donation and support : paypal.me oubouslam a completely free autocad tutorial series containing approximately 70 video a recorded tutorial in cad for the cad and essential production skills module level 4 ba(hons) in theatre and performance video simplified in 3ds max 2017 youtu.be vbv4t petrg subtract operands using boolean subtract. hi creators, now that we know how to create new mesh with booleans, let’s learn how to quickly clean up the mesh. the issue an introduction to how boolean operations can be used to create more complicated components than the basic primitive in this maya tutorial for beginners, we will go over the boolean tools in maya 2022. enjoy! please comment, like & subscribe!
Conclusion
Having examined the subject matter thoroughly, there is no doubt that the post delivers helpful knowledge about Solved Invalid Boolean Autodesk Community. From start to finish, the writer illustrates an impressive level of expertise on the topic. Especially, the discussion of X stands out as particularly informative. Thank you for taking the time to this article. If you have any questions, feel free to reach out via email. I look forward to hearing from you. Additionally, below are some similar content that you may find useful:
2,335,311
3ds Max Boolean Repair Method Suggestions And Discussion
Prepare to be captivated by the magic that 3ds Max Boolean Repair Method Suggestions And Discussion has to offer. Our dedicated staff has curated an experience tailored to your desires, ensuring that your time here is nothing short of extraordinary. Join subtract boolean panel is steps the you to of on scenarios a button objects intersect it list the following fix to allows problem is create follow and The compound can cut in list and objects- them- found you
3ds Max Boolean Repair Method Suggestions And Discussion Youtube
3ds Max Boolean Repair Method Suggestions And Discussion Youtube
(subscriber request) on how to prepare and repair a boolean operation. The boolean button is found on the create panel in the compound objects list; it allows you to join, subtract, intersect, and cut objects. following is a list of problem scenarios and steps you can follow to fix them. tip: before performing a boolean operation, you should save your scene or use edit hold.
3ds Max использование Boolean Youtube
3ds Max использование Boolean Youtube
Hi @csthv999z4. the invalid boolean message is often the result of using a mesh as an operand in the boolean operation which has overlapping vertices or polygons. you did not show the mesh that is generating the error, but since you describe it as «complex» it very likely has some overlapping areas that proboolean cannot handle. The boolean button is found on the create panel in the compound objects list; it allows you to join, subtract, intersect, and cut objects. following is a list of problem scenarios and steps you can follow to fix them. Modify panel > make a selection > modifier list > object space modifiers > boolean default menu: make a selection > modifiers menu > parametric deformers > boolean model provided by: fausto de martini the boolean modifier combines objects into a single mesh by performing a boolean operation (s). Creases or ridges might be caused by a boolean operation between an object that has very few faces and an object that has considerably more faces, for example, when you subtract a complex freeform object from a simple box. 3ds max tessellates the surface of the box so there are additional faces for the subtraction. unfortunately, the faces are.
урок 12 Boolean в 3ds Max Youtube
урок 12 Boolean в 3ds Max Youtube
Modify panel > make a selection > modifier list > object space modifiers > boolean default menu: make a selection > modifiers menu > parametric deformers > boolean model provided by: fausto de martini the boolean modifier combines objects into a single mesh by performing a boolean operation (s). Creases or ridges might be caused by a boolean operation between an object that has very few faces and an object that has considerably more faces, for example, when you subtract a complex freeform object from a simple box. 3ds max tessellates the surface of the box so there are additional faces for the subtraction. unfortunately, the faces are. When attempting to use boolean or proboolean on certain objects within a scene in 3ds max, the operation displays errors and the model disappears. 3ds max invalid boolean 3ds max check operands for self intersection boolean operation is applied to poor or incorrect model geometry. Default menu: select an object. > > > for creating compound objects, which has an alternate workflow and some other options. for most purposes however, the new dual precision boolean algorithm offers the most powerful and intuitive method for accurately assembling compound objects. example with operands and their operation icons.
3ds Max Test Boolean In 3ds Max 2017 Youtube
3ds Max Test Boolean In 3ds Max 2017 Youtube
When attempting to use boolean or proboolean on certain objects within a scene in 3ds max, the operation displays errors and the model disappears. 3ds max invalid boolean 3ds max check operands for self intersection boolean operation is applied to poor or incorrect model geometry. Default menu: select an object. > > > for creating compound objects, which has an alternate workflow and some other options. for most purposes however, the new dual precision boolean algorithm offers the most powerful and intuitive method for accurately assembling compound objects. example with operands and their operation icons.
3ds Max.boolean Repair Method Suggestions And Discussion
3ds Max.boolean Repair Method Suggestions And Discussion
(subscriber request) on how to prepare and repair a boolean operation. i have had several questions around the new boolean compound object, so i thought i would put this together. while we don’t this 3ds max tutorial is show you how to make well with boolean tools fast and easily, check it out!!! 3ds max boolean. the smarter way to render and manage scene renderstacks for 3dsmax renderstacks renderstacks how to fix black polygon in 3ds max. ▭▭▭▭▭▭▭▭▭▭▭▭▭▭▭▭▭▭ if you want to support the channel: in this video i will show you how to use retopology and proboolean for even basic modeling in 3ds max. i’ve been unable to successfully use the booleans operation in 3ds max 2018 does anyone know what i need to do for these to full video: youtu.be dvyeoqqffe8 subscribe: channel ucqqg5q15mscckxp3do4x6bw learn autodesk 3ds max chapter 6 boolean operations with pro boolean brought to you by autodesk certified instructor boolean vs proboolean comparison in 3dsmax |#quicklearn comparing how proboolean and boolean works on different type of
Conclusion
Having examined the subject matter thoroughly, it is evident that the post offers valuable information about 3ds Max Boolean Repair Method Suggestions And Discussion. Throughout the article, the author presents a wealth of knowledge about the subject matter. In particular, the section on Y stands out as a key takeaway. Thank you for the post. If you have any questions, feel free to reach out through the comments. I am excited about your feedback. Furthermore, here are a few similar content that might be interesting: